How Much Is Tesla Insurance a Month in 2026?
How much is Tesla Insurance a month? The short answer: the national average is $168/month through Tesla Insurance, or about $215/month through traditional insurers like GEICO, State Farm, and Progressive. But your actual cost can range anywhere from $119 to $435/month depending on which Tesla you drive, where you live, your Safety Score, and your coverage level.
Let us break down exactly how much Tesla Insurance costs a month for every model, in every state, and at every Safety Score level so you know exactly what to budget.
Tesla Insurance Monthly Cost by Model (2026)
How Your Safety Score Changes How Much Tesla Insurance Costs a Month
The biggest variable in how much Tesla Insurance costs a month is your Safety Score. Tesla tracks five driving behaviors in real time and adjusts your premium monthly:
Safety Score Impact on Monthly Premium (Model Y)
How Much Is Tesla Insurance a Month by State?
Location is the second biggest factor in how much Tesla Insurance costs a month. Here are the 10 most expensive and 10 cheapest states:
| State | Model 3/mo | Model Y/mo | Model S/mo | Cybertruck/mo |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Michigan | $225 | $238 | $385 | $412 |
| Florida | $212 | $225 | $362 | $389 |
| Louisiana | $198 | $212 | $348 | $378 |
| New York | $192 | $205 | $338 | $365 |
| California | $178 | $188 | $312 | $342 |
| National Avg | $148 | $156 | $250 | $280 |
| Ohio | $135 | $142 | $228 | $255 |
| Wisconsin | $128 | $135 | $218 | $248 |
| Utah | $122 | $128 | $205 | $238 |
| Idaho | $115 | $122 | $195 | $225 |
| Maine | $108 | $115 | $188 | $218 |
For state-specific details, check our Tesla Insurance availability by state guide or explore the EV Insurance Map.
Tesla Insurance vs Traditional Insurers: Monthly Cost Comparison
For detailed comparisons, see Tesla Insurance vs GEICO vs Progressive and Tesla Insurance vs State Farm vs Allstate.
How to Pay Less Per Month for Tesla Insurance
- Maximize your Safety Score - Learn the strategies in our Safety Score guide
- Compare at least 5 insurers - See our cheapest Tesla Insurance rankings
- Bundle policies - Multi-policy discounts save 15-25%
- Increase deductible - $1,000+ deductible reduces monthly cost by 10-15%
- Ask about EV discounts - Many states offer EV-specific discounts
Visit Tesla Insurance to get a quote directly through the Tesla app.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is Tesla Insurance a month for a Model 3? Tesla Insurance for a Model 3 costs an average of $148/month for the Standard Range and $188/month for the Performance. See our Model 3 insurance deep dive for details.
How much is Tesla Insurance a month for a Model Y? A Model Y averages $156/month through Tesla Insurance (Standard) and $198/month for Performance.
Is Tesla Insurance cheaper per month than GEICO? Yes, on average Tesla Insurance is 15-18% cheaper than GEICO for Tesla vehicles. The gap is larger with higher Safety Scores. Read our full comparison.
Can I pay Tesla Insurance monthly? Yes, Tesla Insurance bills monthly by default with no extra fees for monthly payment. Most traditional insurers charge 5-10% more for monthly vs 6-month payment.
How much does Tesla Insurance cost a month for a new driver? New drivers (under 25) pay approximately $280-$350/month for a Model 3 through Tesla Insurance. See our young drivers guide.
Why did my Tesla Insurance go up this month? Your monthly premium changes based on Safety Score. If your score dropped due to hard braking, aggressive turns, or forward collision warnings, your premium increases.
---
For the full picture of Tesla Insurance costs, read our Tesla Insurance Ultimate Guide 2026. Data from Tesla and state insurance department filings.