Most Expensive EVs to Insure: New vs Used
EV Insurance Basics 8 min read 2026-06-08 15:06:07

Most Expensive EVs to Insure: New vs Used

Compare insurance costs for new and used electric vehicles, including the most expensive EVs to insure, to save on premiums and make informed decisions

Meet Emily, who owned a brand new Tesla Model 3. Her insurance premium was a whopping $2,500 per year. But after switching to a used 2018 BMW iX, her premium dropped to $1,800. That's a savings of $700, just by going used. Sound familiar? Know what the kicker is? She didn't have to sacrifice much in terms of features or performance.

COMPARISON — Electric Vehicles vs Gas Guzzlers

Insurance costs for electric vehicles (EVs) are often compared to their gas-powered counterparts. But what about the cost of insuring new vs used EVs? Is it really cheaper to insure a used EV? Well, actually, it's not that simple. The cost of insurance depends on various factors, including the make and model of the vehicle, its age, and the driver's history. For instance, a used 2019 Hyundai Ioniq 5 might have a lower insurance premium than a brand new Rivian, simply because it's less expensive to replace.

That being said, some EVs are more expensive to insure than others. The most expensive EVs to insure tend to be high-end models like the Tesla Model S and the Porsche Taycan. These vehicles are not only pricey to purchase, but they're also costly to repair and replace. On the other hand, more affordable EVs like the Nissan Leaf and the Chevrolet Bolt tend to have lower insurance premiums. But, can you really save money by buying a used EV?

The answer is, it depends. If you're looking at a used EV that's only a few years old, the savings might not be as significant as you think. For example, a used 2020 Tesla Model Y might still have a relatively high insurance premium, simply because it's a Tesla. But, if you're looking at an older model, like a 2015 Nissan Leaf, the savings could be substantial. Know what the best part is? You can often find used EVs with similar features and performance to their newer counterparts, but at a lower price point.

7 Most Expensive EVs to Insure

Here are the top 7 most expensive EVs to insure, based on data from various insurance companies:

  1. 1. Tesla Model S - $2,800 per year
  2. 2. Porsche Taycan - $2,500 per year
  3. 3. Audi e-tron - $2,300 per year
  4. 4. Jaguar I-PACE - $2,200 per year
  5. 5. Tesla Model X - $2,100 per year
  6. 6. Rivian R1T - $2,000 per year
  7. 7. BMW iX - $1,900 per year

These numbers are estimates, but they give you an idea of what to expect. Wild, right? The most expensive EVs to insure are often the ones that are most desirable.

But, what about the cost of insuring a used EV? Well, it's not always cheaper. For instance, a used 2018 Tesla Model S might still have a higher insurance premium than a brand new Hyundai Ioniq 5. This is because the Tesla is a more expensive vehicle to replace, even if it's used. On the other hand, a used 2015 Nissan Leaf might have a significantly lower insurance premium than a brand new Tesla Model 3. It really depends on the specific vehicle and the insurance company.

New vs Used EV Insurance Cost Comparison
New vs Used EV Insurance Cost Comparison | Source: evinsuranceguide.com

HONEST_OPINION — The Truth About Insuring Used EVs

Let's be real, insuring a used EV can be a bit of a gamble. You never know what kind of shape the vehicle is in, or what kind of history it has. But, if you do your research and find a good deal on a used EV, it can be a great way to save money on insurance. Just remember, the most expensive EVs to insure are often the ones that are most desirable. So, if you're looking at a used Tesla or Porsche, be prepared for a higher insurance premium.

That being said, there are some great deals to be found on used EVs. For instance, a used 2019 Chevrolet Bolt might have a lower insurance premium than a brand new Nissan Leaf. This is because the Bolt is a more established model, and insurance companies have more data on its performance and reliability. On the other hand, a used 2018 Tesla Model X might have a higher insurance premium than a brand new Audi e-tron. It really depends on the specific vehicle and the insurance company.

Pro tip: When shopping for insurance, make sure to compare rates from multiple companies. Some companies, like Geico and Progressive, offer discounts for EV owners. Others, like State Farm and Allstate, might have higher premiums for certain models. Do your research and find the best deal for your specific vehicle.

MYTH_BUST — The Myth of Cheap Used EV Insurance

There's a common myth that used EVs are always cheaper to insure. But, that's not always the case. As we discussed earlier, the cost of insurance depends on various factors, including the make and model of the vehicle, its age, and the driver's history. So, just because a used EV is older, doesn't mean it's automatically cheaper to insure.

In fact, some used EVs might even be more expensive to insure than their newer counterparts. For instance, a used 2015 Tesla Model S might have a higher insurance premium than a brand new Hyundai Ioniq 5. This is because the Tesla is a more expensive vehicle to replace, even if it's used. On the other hand, a used 2019 Nissan Leaf might have a lower insurance premium than a brand new Rivian R1T. It really depends on the specific vehicle and the insurance company.

But, what about the cost of maintenance and repairs? Don't used EVs tend to be more expensive to maintain and repair? Well, actually, that's not always the case. Many used EVs have already taken their biggest depreciation hit, so the cost of maintenance and repairs might not be as significant as you think. Plus, many EVs have fewer moving parts than gas-powered vehicles, which means they tend to be less prone to mechanical issues.

WARNING — Hidden Costs of Insuring Used EVs

When shopping for insurance on a used EV, there are some hidden costs to watch out for. For instance, some insurance companies might charge higher premiums for used EVs that have been involved in accidents or have had previous owners. Others might charge more for used EVs that have high mileage or are no longer under warranty. So, make sure to do your research and find an insurance company that offers fair rates for your specific vehicle.

And, don't forget to consider the cost of replacement parts. If your used EV is involved in an accident, the cost of replacing parts can be significant. For instance, a used Tesla Model S might require expensive replacement parts, like a new battery pack or electric motor. On the other hand, a used Nissan Leaf might have more affordable replacement parts, like a new battery or electric motor.

FAQs

#### What is the most expensive EV to insure?

The most expensive EV to insure is often the Tesla Model S, with an average annual premium of $2,800. However, this can vary depending on the specific trim level, options, and driver history.

#### How much can I save by buying a used EV?

The amount you can save by buying a used EV depends on the specific vehicle and insurance company. However, you can often save $500-$1,000 per year on insurance premiums by buying a used EV instead of a new one.

#### What factors affect the cost of insuring a used EV?

The cost of insuring a used EV depends on various factors, including the make and model of the vehicle, its age, mileage, and driver history. Additionally, the cost of replacement parts and the vehicle's overall condition can also impact insurance premiums.

#### Can I get a discount on insurance for my used EV?

Yes, some insurance companies offer discounts for used EVs, especially if they have a good safety record or are equipped with advanced safety features. Additionally, some companies offer discounts for EV owners who have a good driving record or have completed a defensive driving course.

#### How do I find the best insurance rates for my used EV?

To find the best insurance rates for your used EV, shop around and compare rates from multiple companies. You can also use online tools or work with an insurance agent to find the best deal for your specific vehicle.

#### What is the average annual premium for a used EV?

The average annual premium for a used EV can vary widely depending on the specific vehicle and insurance company. However, on average, you can expect to pay around $1,500-$2,000 per year for insurance on a used EV.

The best policy is the one you actually understand. — Alex

Keep Reading