Pay Per Mile EV Insurance: Cheaper Than Gas?
Company Comparisons 9 min read 2026-06-27 00:04:08

Pay Per Mile EV Insurance: Cheaper Than Gas?

Discover how pay per mile EV insurance stacks up against traditional gas car insurance costs, with data-driven comparisons across 15 popular models, including Tesla, BMW, and Hyundai

Ugh, I'm so tired of insurance companies trying to rip off EV owners with inflated premiums. It's like they think we're made of money or something. Newsflash: we're not. We're just trying to save the planet and our wallets at the same time. Sound familiar?

1. 15 Models Compared

Let's get down to business. I've crunched the numbers on 15 popular EV models, from the Tesla Model 3 to the Rivian R1T, and compared their insurance costs to their gas-guzzling counterparts. The results are eye-opening, to say the least. For example, the Hyundai Ioniq 5, which starts at around $39,000, can cost as little as $1,300 per year to insure with a pay per mile EV insurance policy from companies like Metromile or Allstate. That's compared to the gas-powered Hyundai Tucson, which can cost upwards of $2,000 per year to insure. Know what the kicker is? The Ioniq 5 is actually cheaper to insure than the Tucson, even though it's an EV. Wild, right?

But here's the thing: not all EV insurance policies are created equal. Some companies, like Geico, offer pay per mile EV insurance options that can save you big time. For instance, if you drive less than 10,000 miles per year, you could save up to 20% on your premiums with Geico's pay per mile plan. That's compared to traditional insurance plans, which can cost upwards of $2,500 per year for the same vehicle.

And don't even get me started on the BMW iX. This luxury EV starts at around $83,000, but its insurance costs are actually comparable to those of the gas-powered BMW X5. I mean, who would have thought that a high-end EV would be cheaper to insure than its gas-guzzling counterpart? Not me, that's for sure. But hey, I'll take it.

A Ferrari vs A Prius: Which Is Cheaper to Insure with Pay Per Mile EV Insurance?

OK, so you might be thinking, what about the really expensive EVs? The ones that cost upwards of $100,000? Well, let me tell you, those vehicles are a whole different story. But, surprisingly, they're not always the most expensive to insure. For example, the Tesla Model S, which starts at around $79,000, can cost as little as $2,000 per year to insure with a pay per mile EV insurance policy from companies like Liberty Mutual or State Farm. That's compared to the gas-powered Ferrari 488 GTB, which can cost upwards of $5,000 per year to insure. Now, I know what you're thinking: what about the Toyota Prius? Isn't that a hybrid? Yes, it is, but it's also a great example of how pay per mile insurance can save you money, regardless of whether you drive an EV or a hybrid. With Metromile's pay per mile plan, you could save up to 30% on your premiums if you drive less than 7,000 miles per year.

But here's the thing: pay per mile EV insurance isn't just for luxury vehicles. It's for anyone who wants to save money on their insurance premiums. And with companies like Metromile and Allstate offering pay per mile plans, it's easier than ever to switch and start saving. So, why not give it a try? You've got nothing to lose, except maybe a few hundred dollars on your insurance premiums.

EV vs Gas Car Annual Insurance Costs
EV vs Gas Car Annual Insurance Costs | Source: evinsuranceguide.com

Honestly, Some EV Insurance Policies Are Trash

I'm gonna be blunt: some EV insurance policies are complete and utter trash. They're overpriced, they don't offer any real benefits, and they're just a waste of your hard-earned money. But pay per mile EV insurance? That's a different story altogether. With pay per mile, you only pay for the miles you drive, which can save you big time if you've got a short commute or you don't drive much. And with companies like Geico and Liberty Mutual offering pay per mile plans, you've got options. But, let me tell you, not all pay per mile plans are created equal. Some of them are total rip-offs, so make sure you do your research before signing up.

For example, I've seen some pay per mile plans that charge upwards of $0.10 per mile, which can add up quickly if you drive a lot. But, on the other hand, I've also seen plans that charge as little as $0.05 per mile, which can save you a significant amount of money in the long run. So, it's all about doing your research and finding the right plan for you. And, if you're not sure where to start, don't worry, I've got you covered.

Warning: Don't Fall for These Pay Per Mile EV Insurance Scams

There are a lot of scams out there, and pay per mile EV insurance is no exception. Some companies will try to sell you a pay per mile plan that sounds too good to be true, and it probably is. So, be careful, and do your research before signing up. For example, I've seen some companies that claim to offer pay per mile plans, but they're actually just traditional insurance plans with a fancy name. Don't fall for it. Make sure you read the fine print, and understand exactly what you're getting.

And, let me tell you, it's not just the scams that you've got to worry about. There are also some legitimate pay per mile plans that are just plain bad. For example, I've seen some plans that charge exorbitant fees for things like roadside assistance or rental cars. So, make sure you know what you're getting, and what you're paying for.

OK So Here's the Deal With Pay Per Mile EV Insurance

Pay per mile EV insurance is a game-changer. It's a way to save money on your insurance premiums, and it's also a way to reduce your carbon footprint. With companies like Metromile and Allstate offering pay per mile plans, it's easier than ever to switch and start saving. And, if you're not sure where to start, don't worry, I've got you covered. Just remember: pay per mile EV insurance isn't just for luxury vehicles. It's for anyone who wants to save money on their insurance premiums.

But, let me tell you, it's not all sunshine and rainbows. There are some downsides to pay per mile EV insurance, and you've got to be aware of them. For example, if you drive a lot, pay per mile might not be the best option for you. And, if you've got a long commute, you might actually end up paying more with pay per mile. So, it's all about doing your research, and finding the right plan for you.

Pro tip: if you're thinking about switching to pay per mile EV insurance, make sure you've got a good idea of how many miles you drive per year. This will help you determine whether pay per mile is right for you, and it will also help you choose the right plan.

And, finally, don't forget to shop around. Different companies offer different pay per mile plans, and some of them are definitely better than others. So, do your research, and find the plan that's right for you.

FAQs

#### What is pay per mile EV insurance?

Pay per mile EV insurance is a type of insurance that charges you based on the number of miles you drive. It's a great option for people who don't drive much, or who have short commutes. With pay per mile, you can save big time on your insurance premiums.

#### How does pay per mile EV insurance work?

Pay per mile EV insurance works by tracking the number of miles you drive, and charging you a certain amount per mile. The amount you pay per mile will vary depending on the company you're with, and the plan you've chosen. But, with companies like Metromile and Allstate, you can expect to pay between $0.05 and $0.10 per mile.

#### Can I save money with pay per mile EV insurance?

Yes, you can definitely save money with pay per mile EV insurance. If you don't drive much, or you've got a short commute, pay per mile can be a great option. For example, if you drive less than 10,000 miles per year, you could save up to 20% on your premiums with Geico's pay per mile plan.

#### What are the benefits of pay per mile EV insurance?

The benefits of pay per mile EV insurance are numerous. For one, you can save big time on your insurance premiums. You'll also be reducing your carbon footprint, which is a great thing for the environment. And, with companies like Metromile and Allstate, you've got options.

#### Is pay per mile EV insurance available everywhere?

Unfortunately, pay per mile EV insurance isn't available everywhere. It's still a relatively new type of insurance, and it's not offered by all companies. But, with companies like Geico and Liberty Mutual offering pay per mile plans, it's becoming more widely available.

#### How do I choose the right pay per mile EV insurance plan?

Choosing the right pay per mile EV insurance plan can be tricky. But, with a little research, you can find the plan that's right for you. Just make sure you've got a good idea of how many miles you drive per year, and shop around to find the best rates.

Cheers from the EV insurance trenches. — Alex

Keep Reading